The short answer is no. A debilitated planet is one sitting in the sign where the texts say its good effects are weakest. That is a real reading and the classical books take it seriously. But they never judge a planet by its sign alone. The house it sits in, the dasha that runs it, its place in the divisional charts and its overall strength all change what it gives. This page explains debilitation, the cancellation rules called Neecha Bhanga, and how to check a fallen planet in your own chart.
What debilitation is
BPHS Ch. 3 Sl. 49-50 gives each of the seven grahas an exaltation sign: the Sun in Aries, the Moon in Taurus, Mars in Capricorn, Mercury in Virgo, Jupiter in Cancer, Venus in Pisces and Saturn in Libra. It then says that in the seventh sign from there "each Grah has its own debilitation". So the Sun falls in Libra, the Moon in Scorpio, Mars in Cancer, Mercury in Pisces, Jupiter in Capricorn, Venus in Virgo and Saturn in Aries. The verse also gives a deepest degree for each, the same degree in the fall sign as in the exaltation sign.
This app follows that rule. Its engine marks a planet anywhere in its fall sign as Debilitated and gives it 0 of 10 for position, the bottom of the dignity ladder it shares with an enemy sign. Rahu and Ketu get no dignity in this app, because the sources disagree on their signs.
What the texts say a fallen planet does
The two main texts are blunt about the sign taken by itself. BPHS Ch. 3 Sl. 59-60 sets out a ratio of effects: full good effects in exaltation, three quarters in moolatrikona, half in own sign, a quarter in a friend's sign, an eighth in a neutral one, and "nil in debilitation, or enemy's camp". Saravali Ch. 4 Sl. 25-26 says the same in its own words: a planet is "futile" in debilitation and "fully inauspicious" there. Saravali Ch. 45 Sl. 15-18 then gives each graha in its fall a short list of effects; for Jupiter they include dishonour and poverty, and for Saturn adversity and pennilessness.
Read on its own, that sounds like a yes. But both texts go on to say that the sign is one input among many, and BPHS gives at least three places where a debilitated planet is read differently.
What else changes the reading
The house it sits in
BPHS Ch. 48 Sl. 1 judges a dasha by sign and house together. A benefic in its fall in an inauspicious house gives adverse effects in its period, it says, while a malefic exalted in an auspicious house does not give unfavourable ones. The adverse reading needs both conditions. A debilitated planet in a good house is not covered by the bad half of that verse.
Raj Yogas built on debilitated planets
BPHS Ch. 39, the chapter on Raj Yoga, names several where a fallen planet is part of the good result. Sl. 19 forms a Raj Yog when the 6th, 8th and 3rd houses hold debilitated grahas while the Lagna lord is exalted or in its own sign and aspects the Lagna. Sl. 20 forms one when the lords of the 6th, 8th and 12th are in fall, in enemy signs or combust, with a strong Lagna lord aspecting the Lagna. Sl. 28 says that even one of the 6th, 8th or 12th lords, debilitated and aspecting the Lagna, gives a Raj Yog, and Sl. 29-31 add a debilitated graha in the 6th, 8th, 3rd or 11th aspecting the Lagna. In these verses a weak lord of a hard house is read as a gain.
Strength and direction of travel
BPHS Ch. 28 Sl. 15-20 says the effects of a house combine the strength of the house and its lord, the benefics and malefics in it, the aspects, dignity and the Ashtakavarga bindus. Dignity is one term in that sum. BPHS Ch. 50 Sl. 73-77 lists 18 conditions that shape a dasha, and Saravali Ch. 41 Sl. 8 adds a direction: a planet moving away from its fall towards its exaltation runs an Arohini, or climbing, Dasa. Saravali Ch. 41 Sl. 7 does still say a planet in its sign of fall yields inauspicious effects in its Dasa, so the texts hold both readings side by side.
Neecha Bhanga: the cancellation rules
Neecha Bhanga means "breaking the fall". It names conditions under which a debilitation is said to be cancelled; when the cancellation is read as a rise, it is called Neecha Bhanga Raja Yoga. A search of BPHS and Saravali in this site's corpus finds no such rule in either. The term appears in Advanced Predictive Astrology Vol. II (Chatterjee), a modern case-study book, which states two conditions in its examples:
- The dispositor (the lord of the sign the fallen planet sits in) is in an angle from both the Moon and the Lagna (p. 38).
- The lord of the sign in which the fallen planet would be exalted is in an angle from the Moon (p. 127).
The book applies these to single charts and does not set out a full list. It also adds a warning of its own: on p. 162 it says a debilitated planet that takes part in a yoga "gives boost but at the same time disturbs the roost". Other authors give other lists, so astrologers can disagree on a cancellation. The angles are the four kendras, the 1st, 4th, 7th and 10th.
Worked example: Jupiter in Capricorn
Take a birth on 5 June 1985 at 02:29 IST in New Delhi. You can enter it in the birth chart calculator and check each figure. The Lagna is Pisces at 27.77 degrees and the Moon is in Sagittarius in the 10th house. Jupiter is in Capricorn, its fall sign, at 23.36 degrees in the 11th house.
| Measure | Jupiter | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Dignity (D1) | Debilitated, 0 of 10 | The sign is its fall |
| Shad Bala | 3.67 of 20, Weak | Position 0, no aspect support, some direction strength (2.67) |
| Vimshopaka Bala | 7.63 of 20, moderate | Exalted in D20, moolatrikona in D7, own sign in D45; debilitated again in D24 and D30 |
| House | 11th | Not one of the 6th, 8th or 12th |
| Dispositor (Saturn) | Exalted in Libra, 8th house, Shad Bala 15.96 Strong | 8th from the Lagna, 11th from the Moon: not an angle |
Now apply the two cancellation conditions by hand. Saturn, the lord of Capricorn, is in the 8th from the Lagna and the 11th from the Moon, so the p. 38 condition is not met. The lord of Cancer, where Jupiter is exalted, is the Moon itself, and the book does not say how to count the Moon from itself, so the p. 127 condition cannot be settled from the text. An astrologer using a longer list might still call this a cancellation; this page cannot.
What the numbers do show is that "debilitated" is not the whole of Jupiter here. It is weak in the birth chart by Shad Bala, but its Vimshopaka score is in the moderate band, because several finer charts place it well. And it sits in the 11th house, not in the 6th, 8th or 12th that the Raj Yog verses of BPHS Ch. 39 treat as the hard houses. The honest reading is "weak by sign, mixed elsewhere", not "bad".
How to check a debilitated planet in your chart
- Open the birth chart calculator with your birth date, time and place. Note any planet marked debilitated, its house, and the sign its lord sits in.
- Open the Shad Bala calculator. A debilitated planet will show 0 for position, so look at what the other five components add, and at the reason line.
- Open the Vimshopaka Bala calculator and read the planet's dignity in the sixteen divisional charts, especially the Navamsa.
- Count the dispositor's house from the Lagna and from the Moon. If it is the 1st, 4th, 7th or 10th from both, the p. 38 condition holds; write that down as a modern author's rule, not the app's verdict.
- Check when the planet's period runs in the Vimshottari Dasha calculator. A fallen planet matters most to the reading while its own dasha or antardasha is running.
What to take care of
Saravali Ch. 41 Sl. 7 reads the Dasa of a planet in its sign of fall as a period of inauspicious effects, and BPHS Ch. 48 Sl. 1 gives adverse dasha effects when a benefic is in its fall in an inauspicious house. Saravali Ch. 45 Sl. 15-18 ties a fallen Jupiter and a fallen Saturn to strain on money and on standing. Where those conditions meet in your chart, the debilitated planet's dasha is a period to be careful with in those areas.
- Keep savings set aside before the planet's dasha or antardasha begins.
- Avoid large unsecured loans and read contracts twice during that period.
- Keep work commitments in writing and records of your own contributions.
- Talk major decisions through with people you trust before you act.
Limits: what no label can settle
- Which cancellation list is right. BPHS and Saravali give none, and modern authors differ. A page or app that says "your debilitation is cancelled" is applying one author's list, and should say whose.
- Whether a planet is "good" or "bad" for you. Debilitation says how able a planet is to give its own good effects. Which effects those are depends on the houses it rules and occupies.
- Anything about Rahu and Ketu. This app gives the nodes no dignity, so it never calls them debilitated.
- What will happen. The texts describe tendencies for a period, not events. This app does not forecast them; the methodology page explains what it computes and how.
For the wider question of how strength is measured, see How do I find the strongest planet in my kundli? and Why do astrologers say my planets are weak?.
- Is a debilitated planet always bad?
- No. BPHS and Saravali say its good effects are at their lowest in the fall sign, but they also weigh its house, strength, dasha and divisional charts, and BPHS Ch. 39 forms Raj Yogas with debilitated planets in some positions.
- What is Neecha Bhanga?
- A set of conditions under which a debilitation is said to be cancelled, such as the dispositor being in an angle from both the Moon and the Lagna. The rules come from later authors; BPHS and Saravali in this site's corpus contain none.
- Does this app show Neecha Bhanga Raja Yoga?
- No. The engine has no cancellation test, a planet in its fall sign is always labelled Debilitated, and the yogas calculator lists no Neecha Bhanga yoga.
- Can a debilitated planet be strong?
- By Shad Bala it starts with 0 for position, so it is usually rated weak. By Vimshopaka Bala it can do better: in the worked example, Jupiter is debilitated in the birth chart but scores 7.63 of 20, moderate, because several divisional charts place it well.
- Is a planet debilitated in the Navamsa the same thing?
- It is a fall in a divisional chart, not in the birth chart. The Vimshopaka Bala calculator counts it with the Navamsa's weight, 3 of 20, so it lowers the score without deciding it.
Shad Bala calculator
Six components, one simplified score out of 20 for each of the seven grahas.
What it needs
Date, time and place
That is more than this article asks for - it only ever takes a date, and sometimes a time, and never a name or a birth place. So this one runs on its own page, which asks for exactly what it needs and stores none of it.
Run it on its own page