The short answer
No chart is good or bad as a whole, and no honest reading grades one that way. The oldest text this app uses, BPHS, says from its third chapter that the Lagna and the grahas show "good and bad effects", both, in the same chart. Everything the text then teaches is a way of weighing those two sides for one area of life at a time. A single verdict on the whole kundli is not a step in that method. You can see the parts of the weighing for your own chart in the free birth chart calculator, the yoga finder and the Shad Bala calculator.
What the texts weigh instead of a verdict
BPHS Ch. 3 Sl. 4-6 defines the grahas, the signs and the Lagna, and says that from them "the native's good and bad effects are deducted". The chapters that follow never add the two sides into one score for the chart. They work at smaller scales:
- Per graha. BPHS Ch. 28 Sl. 6 gives each graha an Isht Phala (benefic tendency) and a Kasht Phala (malefic tendency), and the Kasht is simply 60 minus the Isht. Every graha carries some of each by construction. The Ishta Phala page explains the arithmetic.
- Per house. BPHS Ch. 28 Sl. 15-20 says the effects of a Bhava are "a combination" of the Bhava's strength and its lord's strength: benefics in it are added, malefics deducted, dignity added, debilitation deducted. The answer is different for each of the twelve bhavas.
- Per conflict. BPHS Ch. 74 Sl. 11-13: when a house has both benefics and malefics, the majority decides; with equal numbers, the stronger side; and "Mixed results should be declared" when neither side is stronger. Mixed is a named outcome in the text, not a failure to decide.
- Per strength. BPHS Ch. 45 Sl. 155 closes its long Avastha chapter with the same instruction: "the good and bad effects should be guessed, assessing the strength and weakness of the Grahas, concerning all the Bhavas".
So the text's own question is never "is this chart good?". It is "how strong is this graha, and what does it touch?", asked again for each graha and each house. That is also why the strength tools exist: BPHS Ch. 7 Sl. 9-12 introduces the 20-point Vimshopaka strength so that "the good and bad effects be declared", and Ch. 27 sets out Shad Bala, ending (Sl. 37-38) with the rule that whatever is promised for a Bhava "will come to pass through the strongest Grah".
What 3,000 charts look like
To see whether some charts are simply good and others simply bad, this page ran the engine over 3,000 birth moments spread across 1985-2060, all for New Delhi (scratch run, 2026-11-18). Three things were counted: how many yogas the engine finds, how many of its dosha checks come back present, and the band each of the seven grahas falls in on the app's Shad Bala scale.
| What was counted | Charts out of 3,000 |
|---|---|
| At least one yoga found (the fewest in any chart was 2, the most 12) | 3,000 |
| At least one dosha flagged present | 2,564 |
| At least one graha in the Weak band | 2,853 |
| At least one graha in the Strong band | 2,040 |
| Both a Strong and a Weak graha | 1,922 |
| All seven grahas Strong | 0 |
| All seven grahas Weak | 0 |
Read the two ends of the table together. Every one of the 3,000 charts had at least two yogas, and most also had a dosha flag and a weak graha. Not one chart was strong everywhere or weak everywhere. A chart with a yoga is the normal case, not a lucky one, and a chart with a dosha flag is also the normal case, not an unlucky one. These are counts of birth moments, not of people, and they describe this engine's rules, not anyone's life.
Worked example: one chart read side by side
Take a birth on 15 June 1990 at 06:00 IST in New Delhi. Anyone can enter it in the birth chart calculator and get the same result. The Ascendant is Gemini at 7.59 degrees and the Moon is in Aquarius in the 9th house.
| Graha | Sign, house | Shad Bala (of 20) | Band |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sun | Taurus, 12th | 12.04 | Medium |
| Moon | Aquarius, 9th | 12.17 | Medium |
| Mars | Pisces, 10th | 11.00 | Medium |
| Mercury | Taurus, 12th | 12.46 | Medium |
| Jupiter | Gemini, 1st | 11.50 | Medium |
| Venus | Aries, 11th | 10.04 | Medium |
| Saturn | Capricorn, 8th (own sign, retrograde) | 11.46 | Medium |
All seven grahas sit in the Medium band. A one-word grade would call this an "average" chart and stop. The detail says much more:
- Yogas. The yoga finder finds five: Durudhura, Ubhayachari, Damini, Argala Raj and Sarala Yoga. Each is a named rule about positions, and what a yoga in your chart means explains why a yoga is a condition met, not a promise.
- A dosha flag, and a mild one. The engine flags Kendradhipathya Dosha as Mild, because Jupiter owns the 7th and 10th houses but not the 1st. Its own note says Jupiter's benefic nature is muted there, not reversed, and is not a warning sign. Mangal Dosha and Kaal Sarp are not present.
- One graha, both sides. Saturn is in its own sign, which gives it the highest positional score of the seven (Sthana 7.5 of 10), and it sits in the 8th house, a dusthana. As lord of the 8th placed in the 8th, it is the very graha that forms Sarala Yoga, a rule that reads a difficult-house lord in a difficult house as turning difficulty round. The same graha is a strength, a difficult-house placement and a yoga at once. The Saturn in the 8th house page reads that placement on its own.
- Same band, different tendencies. On BPHS's Isht and Kasht scale the Sun has an Isht Phala of 50.62 and a Kasht Phala of 9.38, while Mercury, in the same sign and house, has 18.33 and 41.67. Two grahas in the same Medium band and the same house lean in opposite directions.
- Mars in the 10th gets the full 4 points of directional strength (Dik Bala), yet 0 for aspects (Drig Bala), because Saturn aspects it.
None of these facts cancels another, and none of them sums to a grade. That is the whole answer to the question in one chart: the kundli is a set of specific strengths and specific cautions, each tied to a graha and a house.
What a balanced reading looks at
Put together from the BPHS rules above and from what this app's calculators compute, a balanced reading of any chart asks these questions, area by area, before it says anything:
- Which house is the question about? Marriage, work and money are different houses with different lords, so they get different answers. A chart is rarely strong or weak in all twelve.
- How strong is the house lord, and the grahas in the house? Dignity first (BPHS Ch. 28 Sl. 10 counts a graha auspicious in exaltation, moolatrikona, own, great friend's and friend's signs, neutral in a neutral sign, and inauspicious in the last three). The dignity page lists them. Then the fuller strength in the Shad Bala calculator and the Vimshopaka Bala calculator.
- Which yogas and which flags touch that house? A yoga or a dosha matters for the houses and grahas it names, not for the whole chart.
- Do the two sides cancel or outweigh each other? BPHS Ch. 74 Sl. 11-13: majority, then strength, then "mixed".
- When is it active? A graha speaks most in its own period. The Vimshottari Dasha calculator shows which graha's period you are in, so a caution in a graha that is not running now is a lower priority than one that is.
What this app shows, and why it gives no grade
This app never prints a single good or bad score for a chart, and that follows the method above. What it does compute, from rules named on the methodology page and sourced on the sources page:
- Shad Bala on a 0-20 scale for the seven grahas, after Kannan's simplified six-part method: position (0-10), aspects (0-3), natural rank (0-1), motion (0-1), direction (0-4) and time (0-1). A combust graha gets no positional points. Strong means 13 or more, Weak 7 or less; the engine's own comments say these cut-offs are its choice, not the source's.
- Isht and Kasht Phala for each graha, from BPHS Ch. 28 Sl. 2-6, shown with the Shad Bala result.
- The yogas the engine tests, each with the positions that formed it, and its dosha checks with a severity.
The Shad Bala and yoga calculators need a birth time, because both depend on the Ascendant. The 0-20 scale is not the Virupa scale of BPHS Ch. 27 Sl. 32-33, which sets a different required total for each graha; the two numbers cannot be compared directly.
Limits: what no score can settle
- No tool can tell you whether your life is good or bad. A kundli is a set of positions and rules about them; whether a rule describes a life is a question arithmetic cannot test.
- Strength scores depend on method. BPHS's full Shad Bala in Virupas, this app's 0-20 version and other apps' versions give different numbers for the same graha, and the band cut-offs here are the engine's own choice.
- Your inputs decide the answer. A wrong birth time can move the Ascendant, every house and with them most strength scores. Why kundlis differ between apps lists the causes.
- A flag is not a verdict. The engine itself calls Kendradhipathya Dosha "not a warning sign", and Mangal Dosha: what it is and is not shows how much one flag depends on which rule is used.
- Nothing here forecasts events. Can astrology predict the future? sets out what the texts claim and what can be tested.
Questions people ask about a good or bad kundli
- Is a kundli with many yogas a good kundli?
- Not on its own. In the 3,000-chart sample every chart had at least two yogas and some had twelve. A yoga is a rule that a set of positions meets; how much it gives depends on the strength of the grahas that form it, which BPHS Ch. 27 Sl. 37-38 makes the deciding factor.
- Does a dosha make my kundli bad?
- No. 2,564 of 3,000 sampled charts had at least one dosha flagged, so a flag is common, and the worked example's only flag is graded Mild by the engine. Read what each flag names and what modifies it, for example on the Kendradhipathya Dosha page.
- My chart has a weak planet. Is that bad?
- It is a caution for the houses that planet rules and occupies, not for the whole chart. 2,853 of the 3,000 sampled charts had at least one graha in the Weak band. Look at which houses it touches and whether its period is running.
- Can I see my own strengths and cautions for free?
- Yes. Enter your birth details with a birth time in the Shad Bala calculator for each graha's strength and Isht and Kasht values, and the yoga finder for the yogas in your chart.
- Why does another app call my kundli bad?
- Different apps use different rules, scales and inputs. This app gives no overall grade, because BPHS weighs good and bad effects house by house. See why kundlis differ between apps.
Shad Bala calculator
Six components, one simplified score out of 20 for each of the seven grahas.
What it needs
Date, time and place
That is more than this article asks for - it only ever takes a date, and sometimes a time, and never a name or a birth place. So this one runs on its own page, which asks for exactly what it needs and stores none of it.
Run it on its own page