A common experience: one app says a chart is Manglik, another says it is not, and an astrologer gives a third answer. Usually nobody has made an arithmetic mistake. Each of them is running a slightly different rule. This page names every setting that changes the answer and measures each one with this app's engine. The rule itself, its source and what it does not mean are covered in Mangal Dosha: what it is and what it is not; this page does not repeat that.
All figures below come from one run: 6,000 birth moments drawn evenly from 1985 to 2060, placed at New Delhi, each put through the same chart engine the calculators use. They are shares of sampled birth moments, not of people.
Cause 1: which houses count
The version most people meet, and the one this app uses, flags Mars in the 1st, 2nd, 4th, 7th, 8th or 12th house. The oldest text in the library that states a rule of this shape is narrower. BPHS Ch. 80 Sl. 47 names four houses only: the 12th, 4th, 7th and 8th from the ascendant. The 1st and 2nd are not in that sloka. The names "Mangal Dosha", "Kuja Dosha" and "Manglik" occur in none of the astrology texts in the library, so neither list can claim the name from a text.
Mars falls in each of the twelve houses about equally often (between 7.8% and 9.2% each in the sample), so dropping two houses removes about a third of the flags. Six houses flagged 50.1% of the sampled moments; the four BPHS houses flagged 33.6%. One chart in six is Manglik under one list and not under the other, before any other setting is touched.
Cause 2: counted from the ascendant or from the Moon
BPHS Ch. 80 Sl. 47 counts from the Lagn, the ascendant. The sloka just before it, on a different yoga, counts "from Lagn, or Candr", from the ascendant or from the Moon, so the text does use both reference points, just not for this rule. Some readings count Mars from the Moon's sign, the Chandra Lagna, as well or instead. This app's own two-chart reading does exactly that when a birth time is missing: it counts houses from the Moon and labels the result with that basis.
The two frames give the same overall share, 50.1% from the ascendant and 50.2% from the Moon, which makes them look interchangeable. They are not. They disagree on 49.4% of sampled moments, close to what two unrelated coin tosses would give. A tool that flags the chart when either frame qualifies flags 74.9%; a tool that needs both flags 25.5%.
| Version of the rule | Share of 6,000 sampled moments flagged |
|---|---|
| Six houses from the ascendant (this app) | 50.1% |
| Six houses from the Moon | 50.2% |
| Six houses from the ascendant or the Moon | 74.9% |
| Six houses from both the ascendant and the Moon | 25.5% |
| Four BPHS houses from the ascendant | 33.6% |
| Six houses, no benefic in or aspecting Mars's house | 19.5% |
| Four BPHS houses, no benefic in or aspecting Mars's house | 12.9% |
Cause 3: which exceptions are applied
BPHS attaches a condition to its rule: Mars must be "without aspect by, or association with any benefic". This app's single-chart flag does not apply that condition, and its code says so. To measure it, the run treated the engine's own benefics (Jupiter, Venus, Mercury and the Moon) as cancelling when one sits in Mars's house or aspects it by the engine's graha drishti rules. That is one reasonable reading of the clause, not the only one. With it, the six-house share falls from 50.1% to 19.5%, and the four-house share from 33.6% to 12.9%.
The second exception is about two charts. BPHS Ch. 80 Sl. 48-49 says the same combination in a man's chart is read the same way, and that if a man and a woman who both have it marry, "the Yog ceases to have any effect". Taking the sample in 3,000 pairs: from the ascendant, 25.2% of pairs had it on both sides, 49.8% on one side and 25.0% on neither. From the Moon the figures were 24.5%, 51.4% and 24.1%. The pair landed in a different one of those three groups under the two frames in 60.7% of pairs, so a matching tool that switches frame changes most pair verdicts.
Many longer lists of cancellations circulate, keyed to Mars's sign or to particular ascendants. None of them is in the texts this app holds, so this page does not list them and the app does not apply them. A tool that applies some of them will flag fewer charts than any row in the table above, by an amount that depends on which ones it chose.
Cause 4: grades and labels
Even when two tools agree that the flag is present, they can describe it differently. This app grades Mars in the 7th or 8th as Moderate and the other four houses as Mild, and has no heavier grade. The BPHS sloka has no grades at all. Tools that score Mangal Dosha as a percentage or in several levels are adding their own scale, and two such scales cannot be compared number for number.
Cause 5: the zodiac, the houses and the birth time
The rule counts houses, so anything that moves the ascendant or Mars across a sign line can change it. This app uses whole-sign houses in the sidereal zodiac with the Lahiri ayanamsa. A different ayanamsa shifts the ascendant and Mars together, so the house count changes only when one of them crosses a sign line and the other does not. In the sample, shifting the zodiac by 0.5 degrees changed the verdict on 1.6% of moments, by 1 degree on 3.3%, and by 2 degrees on 6.0%. The ayanamsa calculator shows the Lahiri value for any date; Lahiri, KP and Raman compared explains why this app gives no number for the others.
A tool that uses unequal houses can put Mars in a different house from whole signs even with the same zodiac; whole-sign vs Placidus houses sets out that difference. The birth time matters most of all, because the ascendant moves far faster than Mars: in the worked example below, two hours move it a whole sign. The parent essay measures how often a small time error flips the verdict, and how accurate a birth time needs to be covers the same question for the whole chart. Whole-chart causes such as time zones and place coordinates are in why a kundli differs between apps.
Worked example: one chart under every version
Take a birth on 1 January 2000 at 12:00 IST in New Delhi. Re-enter it in the birth chart calculator to see the same positions. The ascendant is Pisces (13.19 degrees into the sign). Mars is in Aquarius, 3.95 degrees into the sign, which is the 12th house from Pisces. The Moon is in Libra, and Aquarius is the 5th sign from Libra. Jupiter and Saturn are in Aries, the 2nd house; Venus is in Scorpio, the 9th; the Sun and Mercury are in Sagittarius, the 10th. No benefic sits in the 12th or aspects it.
| Version | Mars counted | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Six houses from the ascendant (this app) | 12th | Present, Mild |
| Four BPHS houses from the ascendant | 12th | Present |
| Four BPHS houses, benefic exception | 12th, no benefic | Present |
| Six houses from the Moon | 5th | Not present |
| Ascendant or Moon | 12th / 5th | Present |
| Ascendant and Moon | 12th / 5th | Not present |
So this one chart is Manglik under four versions and not under two. The ascendant is 13.19 degrees into Pisces and Mars 3.95 degrees into Aquarius, so an ayanamsa different from Lahiri by less than about 3.9 degrees would leave both in their signs and change nothing here. The birth time is a different matter. Two hours later, at 14:00 IST, the ascendant is Aries, Mars is in the 11th, and every ascendant-based version says not present. Running the Mangal Dosha calculator at both times shows that switch.
What this app does, and why
The single-chart flag uses six houses from the ascendant, whole signs, Lahiri, with no exceptions applied, and needs a birth time and place. That rule was kept deliberately because it is the version most readers compare against; the code comment and the parent essay both say plainly that it is wider than the BPHS sloka. The result sentence calls Mars there "friction in partnership timing, not a fixed outcome" and notes that many traditions treat a shared dosha as neutralised. That is the engine's wording; the corpus itself holds the rule only as BPHS Ch. 80 states it.
For two charts, the signed-in compatibility reading applies the both-partners exception from BPHS Ch. 80 Sl. 48-49 and lists a shared flag as "Manglik on both sides". Without a birth time it counts from the Moon and says so. The free match tool and the kundli matching calculator read Guna Milan from the Moon only. How the app states its conventions is set out on the methodology page, and the texts it draws on are listed on the sources page.
Limits: what no tool can settle
- Which version is "correct" is a question of convention. The library holds one sloka of this shape, with four houses and two exceptions; the six-house list and the Moon count are later practice, and no text here ranks them.
- The benefic clause has more than one reasonable reading (which grahas count as benefic, which aspects count, whether a benefic in its weakness still cancels). Each reading gives a different share.
- No figure on this page measures what happens in marriages. The sample counts how often a rule fires, not whether the rule describes anything.
- A missing or rounded birth time cannot be repaired by any setting. Without a time, only the Moon frame is available, and that is a different rule, not a fallback for the same one. Why astrologers give different answers covers the same problem across a whole reading.
- Why does one app say I am Manglik and another says I am not?
- Most often the two apps use different rules: six houses or four, counted from the ascendant or the Moon, with or without exceptions. In this app's sample the ascendant and Moon versions alone disagreed on 49.4% of birth moments. A different birth time or place entered is the next thing to check.
- Which version does BPHS use?
- BPHS Ch. 80 Sl. 47 names Mars in the 12th, 4th, 7th or 8th from the ascendant, without aspect by or association with a benefic. Sl. 48-49 apply it to men as well and say it ceases to have effect when both partners have it. The text does not use the name Mangal Dosha.
- Why does this app use six houses if BPHS names four?
- Because the six-house list is the convention most readers compare against, and the app says openly that it is wider than the sloka. The parent essay sets the two side by side.
- Should Mangal Dosha be checked from the Moon as well?
- The library has no text that counts this rule from the Moon. Some readings do; this app does so only in its two-chart reading when no birth time is on file, and labels it. Checking both frames flags 74.9% of sampled moments, so it widens the rule a great deal.
- Does a different ayanamsa change Mangal Dosha?
- Sometimes. Because the ascendant and Mars move together, only charts with one of them near a sign line change. In the sample a 1-degree shift changed 3.3% of verdicts and a 2-degree shift 6.0%.
- If both partners are Manglik, is it cancelled?
- BPHS Ch. 80 Sl. 48-49 says so, and this app's two-chart reading applies it. About a quarter of sampled pairs had it on both sides. Try the calculator on each chart, then compare them.
Mangal Dosha
Which house Mars holds from your ascendant, and whether that is one of the six.
What it needs
Date, time and place
That is more than this article asks for - it only ever takes a date, and sometimes a time, and never a name or a birth place. So this one runs on its own page, which asks for exactly what it needs and stores none of it.
Run it on its own page