"Will this deal go through?", "Will I get this job?", "Is this opportunity worth it?" These are questions about one matter, asked at one moment. A birth chart is cast once, for a whole life, and answers them only indirectly. Prashna (horary astrology) casts a fresh chart for the moment the question is asked, at the place where the person asking stands, and reads that chart for that one question.
This page goes deep on one rule set: the third chapter of Daivajna Vallabha, titled "Gains and Losses", which this app's Prashna calculator uses for its "Money, gains & opportunity" category ("Will this deal, job or opportunity work out", in the app's own words). It sets out exactly what the engine scores, what the chapter says in full, and one worked example. For the feature as a whole, see the Prashna feature page.
How a gain or loss question is read, rule by rule
The chart of the moment is an ordinary chart: the same rising sign (lagna), the same twelve houses and the same nine grahas as any birth chart, computed by the same code. Only the moment and the method of reading differ. The engine then applies two rules from Ch. III and keeps a single running score that starts at zero.
Step 1: grahas in the 11th, 7th, 5th and 3rd houses (Sl. 1)
The engine looks at four houses: the 11th, the 7th, the 5th and the 3rd. For each benefic found in any of them it adds one point; for each malefic it takes one point away. Every graha is checked, so three benefics in those houses add three points, and a benefic and a malefic in the same house cancel out.
- Benefics, for this rule: Jupiter, Venus, Mercury and the Moon. The engine uses a fixed list and does not check whether the Moon is waxing or waning, or whether Mercury sits with a malefic.
- Malefics, for this rule: the Sun, Mars, Saturn, Rahu and Ketu.
- A graha in any other house (the 1st, 2nd, 4th, 6th, 8th, 9th, 10th or 12th) does not move the score at all under this step.
Step 2: the nature of the rising sign (Sl. 5)
Every sign is movable, fixed or dual. The engine reads the rising sign's nature from the same table the Kundali uses:
| Rising sign | Signs | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed | Taurus, Leo, Scorpio, Aquarius | +1 (a gain in position) |
| Movable | Aries, Cancer, Libra, Capricorn | -1 (that gain does not happen) |
| Dual | Gemini, Virgo, Sagittarius, Pisces | 0 (the text says both results happen) |
For the terms, see sthira (fixed) rashi, chara (movable) rashi and dvisvabhava (dual) rashi.
Step 3: the verdict
The two steps are added. A total of 1 or more reads Favourable, -1 or less reads Testing, and exactly 0 reads Mixed. Because Step 2 always applies, this question type always has at least one signal: unlike the travel or lost-item readings, it never returns Unclear. Each reason is printed beside the verdict with its sloka number, so the reader can see what pushed the score which way.
What Daivajna Vallabha Ch. III says
Daivajna Vallabha is a horary text attributed to Varahamihira; this app's sources page lists the edition it works from. Its third chapter, "Gains and Losses", is short: five slokas. The engine scores parts of two. Here is the whole chapter, so the reader can see what is used and what is not.
Sloka 1: the gain houses, and two more groups
The first sentence is the rule the engine scores: benefics in the 11th, 7th, 5th and 3rd houses "cause gain", and malefics there "do not yield desired result". The sloka goes on with two further groups that the engine does not score. Benefics in the 10th or 7th are read as bestowing status and position, and benefics in the 2nd, 5th or 1st as conferring respect, honour and wealth.
So the 5th and 7th appear in more than one list. The 10th, 2nd and 1st houses appear only in the parts the engine leaves aside, which is why a benefic in the 10th, for instance, adds nothing to this score.
Sloka 2: the Moon and its aspects
Sl. 2 reads the Moon. Placed in the 7th, 10th, 2nd, 6th, 3rd or 11th and aspected by benefics, it is read as good results, or gains, through a woman. Placed in the 1st, 3rd, 5th, 8th or 9th and aspected by malefics, it is read as fear, failure in an undertaking and spending of wealth, while benefics in those houses confer status, wealth and property. This depends on aspects, and the engine does not test it.
Sloka 3: the quick-gain pattern
Sl. 3 says that with benefics in the trikonas and kendras, and malefics in the 3rd, 6th and 11th, the querist gains "very quickly"; the opposite arrangement produces no gain. Notice that this sloka puts malefics in the 3rd and 11th as a good sign, where Sl. 1 reads malefics in the same houses as not yielding the result. The text gives the two rules side by side and does not reconcile them. The engine scores only Sl. 1, so a malefic in the 3rd or 11th always counts against.
Sloka 4: an older view on immediate gain
Sl. 4 is quoted from two earlier authorities, Satyacharya and Acharya Bali: the Moon in the 4th or 7th with the Sun in the ascendant or the 10th means monetary gains immediately. The engine does not test it.
Sloka 5: the rising sign
The last sloka is the one the engine scores in full: Taurus, Leo, Scorpio or Aquarius rising, the person "gains some position (status) or post"; a movable sign, "this does not happen"; a dual sign, "both results happen". Notice that this sloka is about position or post, not money as such. The engine adds it to the same score as Sl. 1, so a job or promotion question and a money question are read by the same two rules.
Worked example: 2 November 2026, 10:00 IST, New Delhi
This is the engine's own run for a question asked at 10:00 IST on 2 November 2026 (04:30 UTC) in New Delhi. Anyone can repeat it in the calculator by entering that moment and place.
| Graha | Sign | House |
|---|---|---|
| Sun | Libra | 12th |
| Moon | Cancer | 9th |
| Mars | Cancer | 9th |
| Mercury (retrograde) | Libra | 12th |
| Jupiter | Leo | 10th |
| Venus (retrograde) | Libra | 12th |
| Saturn (retrograde) | Pisces | 5th |
| Rahu | Aquarius | 4th |
| Ketu | Leo | 10th |
Step 1. Of the four gain houses, only the 5th is occupied, by Saturn, a malefic: -1. The 11th, 7th and 3rd are empty. Jupiter is in the 10th, and Mercury and Venus are in the 12th, so none of the benefics touches this step.
Step 2. Scorpio is a fixed sign: +1, read as a gain in position.
Step 3. The total is 0, and the verdict is Mixed. The engine prints two reasons: Saturn in the 5th house, read as not yielding the desired result (Ch. 3, Sloka 1), and the ascendant rising in Scorpio, read as gaining some status or position (Ch. 3, Sloka 5).
Reading it back against the full chapter shows what the score leaves out. Jupiter in the 10th is a benefic in one of the houses Sl. 1 reads for status and position, but that half of the sloka is not scored. The Moon is in the 9th, a house Sl. 2 lists, but Sl. 2 turns on aspects, which the engine does not test here. Sl. 4 needs the Moon in the 4th or 7th, and the Moon is in the 9th, so it would not apply in this chart anyway. A Mixed verdict, in this app's words, means the chart of the moment pulls both ways; it is the text's reading of the moment, not a forecast of the deal.
What a gain or loss prashna does not do
- One moment, one question. The chart answers the question asked at that moment. Asking again a few minutes later gives a new rising sign sooner or later, and so a new chart, not a second opinion on the first.
- Two rules, not the whole chapter. Only the first sentence of Sl. 1 and all of Sl. 5 are scored. The status and honour groups of Sl. 1, the Moon and aspect rules of Sl. 2, the pattern of Sl. 3 and the view quoted in Sl. 4 are left out, as described above.
- No amounts, no dates. The text does not say how much will be gained or when, and neither does the engine. Sl. 3 and Sl. 4 speak of "very quickly" and "immediately", and neither is modelled.
- No birth chart. The reading does not look at your own lagna, Moon sign or dashas. A birth chart and a prashna answer different questions.
- Not financial advice. Whether a deal is sound, a contract fair or a job offer right for you is a matter for the numbers, the paperwork and people you trust. A prashna reading says nothing about the deal itself.
- Questions this app does not answer. Daivajna Vallabha also has chapters on death against recovery, warfare and the sex of a child. This app does not build them, and a gain or loss question here never touches them. The methodology page explains this for the whole app.
The other question types read other chapters of the same text: a general yes or no question reads Ch. XV house by house; travel reads Ch. IV; a lost item reads Ch. IX for recoverability only; relationship timing keeps two slokas of Ch. XII. The number prashna question clock is a numerology method and does not cast a chart.
Questions people ask about gain or loss prashna
- Why does a benefic in the 10th not help the score?
- Sl. 1 reads benefics in the 10th or 7th as bestowing status and position, but the engine scores only the sloka's first sentence, about the 11th, 7th, 5th and 3rd. A benefic in the 7th counts; one in the 10th does not.
- Is the Sun counted as a malefic?
- Yes. The engine's fixed malefic list is the Sun, Mars, Saturn, Rahu and Ketu, so the Sun in the 11th, 7th, 5th or 3rd takes a point away.
- Can a gain or loss reading come back Unclear?
- No. The rising sign rule always applies, so there is always at least one reason. With a dual rising sign and nothing in the four gain houses, the score is 0 and the verdict is Mixed.
- Does Testing mean I will lose money?
- No. Testing means the two scored rules lean against the gain asked about in this chart of the moment. It is the text's reading of that moment, not a forecast, and it says nothing about amounts.
- Do Sl. 1 and Sl. 3 disagree?
- On malefics in the 3rd and 11th, yes: Sl. 1 reads them as not yielding the result, while Sl. 3 places malefics there in its quick-gain pattern. The text gives both. The engine follows Sl. 1 only.
- Can I use this for a job or promotion question?
- The app's category covers "this deal, job or opportunity". Sl. 5 speaks of gaining a position or post, so it fits that kind of question directly. Ask it in the Prashna calculator and the same two rules are scored.