Astro Clock AI
PrashnaPrashna · 3 of 6

Prashna for a general question: how a yes or no is judged

How a general yes/no question is judged from the chart of the moment: the Daivajna Vallabha Ch. XV house rules and the Ch. I state of the ascendant lord this app scores, a worked example, and the limits.

Article text is currently English only. The calculation below and the rest of the interface follow your chosen language.

In short

A general prashna reads the chart of the moment the question is asked. Following Daivajna Vallabha Ch. XV, this app scores each benefic as helping in every house but the 6th and each malefic as helping only in the 3rd, 6th, 10th or 11th, then weighs the ascendant lord's state from Ch. I most heavily. A total of 2 or more reads favourable, -2 or less testing, anything between mixed.

"Will this work out?" Many questions have no special chapter of their own: a meeting, an application, a plan that is not about money, travel, a lost thing or a match. Prashna (horary astrology) answers such questions from a chart cast for the moment the question is asked, at the place where the person asking stands. A birth chart is cast once, for life; a prashna chart is cast for one question and read for that question only.

This page goes deep on the rule this app uses for that general case: the house-by-house table of Daivajna Vallabha Ch. XV, combined with the state (avastha) of the ascendant lord from Ch. I. It shows exactly what the engine behind the Prashna calculator counts, what the text says, where the engine simplifies the text, and one full worked example. For the feature as a whole, see the Prashna feature page. Questions with their own rule sets have their own pages: gain or loss, travel, a lost item and relationship timing.

How a general question is judged, rule by rule

The engine casts the chart of the moment with the same astronomy as a birth chart: the rising sign (the lagna) at that minute and place, the nine grahas, and their houses counted from the lagna. The words of the question play no part in the arithmetic; only the moment, the place and the category you choose do. It then adds up one point at a time.

  1. Each natural benefic (Jupiter, Venus, Mercury and the Moon, the list this app uses everywhere) adds 1 point in any house except the 6th, and takes away 1 point in the 6th.
  2. Each natural malefic (the Sun, Mars, Saturn, Rahu and Ketu) adds 1 point in an upachaya house, the 3rd, 6th, 10th or 11th, and takes away 1 point in any other house.
  3. The lord of the rising sign is then judged by its dignity in the chart of the moment: exalted or moolatrikona adds 2, own or friendly sign adds 1, debilitated or enemy sign takes away 2, and a neutral sign adds nothing. This one planet can move the total by as much as two ordinary placements, because Ch. I Sl. 2 puts the states of planets first.
  4. The total gives the verdict: 2 or more is shown as favourable, -2 or less as testing, and anything from -1 to 1 as mixed. The general category always has some signal, so it never returns "unclear".
FactorAddsTakes away
Benefic (Jupiter, Venus, Mercury, Moon)1, in any house but the 6th1, in the 6th
Malefic (Sun, Mars, Saturn, Rahu, Ketu)1, in the 3rd, 6th, 10th or 11th1, in any other house
Ascendant lord exalted or moolatrikona2
Ascendant lord in own or friendly sign1
Ascendant lord debilitated or in an enemy sign2
The scoring in the prashna general calculation, the app's code.

The state of the ascendant lord gets a name from Ch. I. The engine maps five of the ten states onto its dignity table: Diptha for exaltation (and moolatrikona), Dina for debilitation (neecha), Swastha for own sign (swakshetra), Mudhitha for a friendly sign and Suptha for an enemy sign. If the lord is within combustion range of the Sun, the name shown is Mushita instead (combustion), though the score still follows the dignity. Friendship here is judged from the chart of the moment itself, its own temporary friendships, not from anyone's birth chart.

What Daivajna Vallabha Ch. XV and Ch. I say

Daivajna Vallabha is a horary text attributed to Varahamihira. Its fifteenth chapter is a general table of what each house shows in a query and what benefics and malefics do there. Sl. 1 names the twelve houses from the ascendant onward as body, treasure, fighting, vehicles, counsel, enemies, path, longevity, mind, occupation, gains and minister. Much of the chapter is written for a king's query about an army, which is why "fighting" and "army" keep appearing.

Sl. 2 is the core of the engine's rule. It says the Sun, Saturn and Mars spoil the house they occupy except the 3rd and the 11th, that the Sun and Mars also do not spoil the 10th, and that benefics make every house flourish except the 6th. It then adds three exceptions: Venus is not good in the 7th, the Moon is not auspicious in the 8th, and the Moon is not good for the house that falls in Leo.

Sl. 3-5 go through the benefics house by house: in the 2nd, wealth; in the 4th, vehicles and friends; in the 9th, fame and wealth; in the 10th, victory in undertakings; in the 11th, much gain. Sl. 6-9 do the same for malefics: decay of wealth in the 2nd, fame in the 3rd, good in the 6th, no good results in the 7th, victory for Mars and the Sun in the 10th but defeat for Saturn there, and victory for all of them in the 11th.

Sl. 9 closes with the rule the engine generalises: the results of malefics in houses other than the upachayas (3, 6, 10 and 11) are the opposite of what benefics give in those houses. Sl. 10 adds qualifications: a malefic happily placed in the ascendant is still praiseworthy, an afflicted benefic is not good there, and a retrograde planet is not good in an angular house.

Ch. I Sl. 3-6 list the ten states. Sl. 7-8 give their results: Diptha, full gain of the object asked about; Dina, impending poverty; Swastha, the object accomplished with wealth, fame and happiness besides; Mudhitha, all-round happiness and the object accomplished; Suptha, danger and accidents; Mushita, loss of wealth. The engine shows these as the text's reading of the moment in milder words ("the matter struggling to succeed as asked" for Dina), never as a forecast about the person.

Where the engine simplifies the text

  • The text names only the Sun, Saturn and Mars in Sl. 2 and adds the Moon in the ascendant line of Sl. 6; the engine applies one malefic rule to the Sun, Mars, Saturn, Rahu and Ketu, and treats the Moon as a benefic throughout.
  • The text spares only the 3rd and 11th for all three malefics and the 10th for the Sun and Mars (Sl. 8 reads Saturn in the 10th as defeat); the engine credits all four upachaya houses, 3, 6, 10 and 11, to every malefic, following the closing rule of Sl. 9.
  • Venus in the 7th and the Moon in the 8th still score +1 in the engine, though Sl. 2 calls them not good. The Leo exception for the Moon is not modelled.
  • Sl. 10 (retrograde planets in angles, a malefic happily placed in the ascendant, an afflicted benefic there) is not modelled, and nor is the Sl. 4 travel line about the 7th.
  • Of the ten states in Ch. I, four need systems this app does not build (planetary war, waxing and waning strength, benefic vargas after rising) and are left out rather than approximated.

Worked example: 2 November 2026, 10:00 IST, New Delhi

For a general question asked at 10:00 IST on 2 November 2026 (04:30 UTC) in New Delhi, the engine casts Scorpio rising in Jyeshtha nakshatra, with the Moon in Cancer in Ashlesha. Scorpio's lord is Mars, and Mars is in Cancer, its sign of debilitation, in the 9th house.

GrahaHouseRulePoints
Jupiter (benefic)10thbenefic outside the 6th+1
Venus (benefic)12thbenefic outside the 6th+1
Mercury (benefic)12thbenefic outside the 6th+1
Moon (benefic)9thbenefic outside the 6th+1
Sun (malefic)12thmalefic outside an upachaya-1
Mars (malefic)9thmalefic outside an upachaya-1
Saturn (malefic)5thmalefic outside an upachaya-1
Rahu (malefic)4thmalefic outside an upachaya-1
Ketu (malefic)10thmalefic in an upachaya+1
Mars as ascendant lordCancerdebilitated: Dina-2
a check script prashna-general-question, run 2026-11-16. Total: +4 from benefics, -3 from malefics, -2 from the lord = -1.

The total is -1, so the engine shows the verdict as mixed. The four benefics all sit outside the 6th and pull upward. Four of the five malefics sit outside the upachaya houses, Rahu in the 4th, Saturn in the 5th, Mars in the 9th and the Sun in the 12th, and pull downward; only Ketu in the 10th scores for. The deciding weight is Mars: as the ascendant lord in its debilitation sign it is in the Dina state, worth -2, which the engine words as the matter "struggling to succeed as asked".

Limits of a general prashna

  • One moment, one question. The chart belongs to the minute and the place it was cast for. Daivajna Vallabha Ch. I Sl. 9-10 says the query should be put once only; asking again until the answer changes is not a second reading.
  • The general category is the fallback. If the question is about money or an opportunity, travel, a lost thing or a match, the dedicated category reads it by its own chapter and should be used instead.
  • It is not a birth chart reading. For lasting patterns, the birth chart and its Chandra lagna are the right tools; a prashna says nothing about who you are.
  • The text says more than the engine reads. Ch. XV Sl. 11-18 judge 36 decanates and later slokas read the navamsa of the ascendant; Sl. 10 and the planet-specific exceptions above are skipped. These are named here so the score is not mistaken for the whole of the chapter.
  • Some questions are not answered at all. Daivajna Vallabha also judges questions about whether a sick person will recover or die, warfare, the sex of a child and most of the spouse lines of Ch. XII; Ch. XV Sl. 6 and Sl. 8 also carry lines about confinement and early death. This app does not answer these and does not read those lines, whatever category is chosen.
  • Ch. I Sl. 9-10 ask the querist to worship the planets before asking, and Sl. 11-13 read omens and the place of asking. The text prescribes propitiation; this app does not, and it reads no omens.

Ch. XV Sl. 30-31 also read the hora (half a sign) for the start of a journey, which this engine does not use. A different method, the numerology question clock, works from the time digits; see number prashna and the question clock. Every source this app draws on is listed on the sources page.

Questions people ask about a general prashna

What does the general category in the Prashna calculator check?
It scores the house of each of the nine grahas in the chart of the moment (benefics help everywhere but the 6th, malefics help only in the 3rd, 6th, 10th and 11th) and adds the dignity of the ascendant lord with double weight. A total of 2 or more is favourable, -2 or less testing, the rest mixed.
Why does the ascendant lord count for more than other planets?
Daivajna Vallabha Ch. I Sl. 2 puts the states of planets first, saying the astrologer who weighs them with the houses "never goes wrong". The engine gives the lord's dignity up to 2 points either way; the exact weight is this app's choice, not a number from the text.
Does the app read the words of my question?
No. The question text is stored for display only. The chart is cast for the moment and place, and the category you pick decides which rule set reads it.
Why did my answer change when I asked again?
The chart is cast for the minute, so a later minute can give a different rising sign. The text asks for the query to be put once; the first reading is the one it means.
Is Venus in the 7th good or bad in a general prashna?
Daivajna Vallabha Ch. XV Sl. 2 says Venus is not good in the 7th. The engine does not model that exception and scores Venus there like any benefic outside the 6th, +1. The page lists this so the score is read with that in mind.
Can a general prashna tell me about health or a court case?
The engine gives a favourable, mixed or testing reading of the moment for any question, but it does not diagnose, forecast an illness or predict a case. For a health matter see a doctor; for a legal one, a lawyer.

Sources for this page